| On September 9-13, 2007, three parliamentarians from Canada and the United Kingdom
traveled to Honduras on an MPs’ Fact-Finding Mission on Mining issues, Alexa McDonough,
(Canada, NDP, Halifax), Spokesperson for the NDP on Foreign Affairs and International Development;
Keith Hill, (UK, Labour, Streatham), parliamentary private secretary to former
Prime Minister Tony Blair; and Stephen Pound (UK, Labour, Ealing North).
Development and Peace and the Catholic Agency for Overseas Development (CAFOD) sponsored
the mission following a request from their partner, Caritas Tegucigalpa, who wanted
help to advocate for a just and responsible mining law in Honduras. Caritas has worked intensively
for mining legislation that puts the interests of the country before those of foreign
mining companies. In addition, it has been working closely with the communities affected by
the environmental and human impact of San Martin, an open pit mine run by Entre Mares, a
subsidiary of Goldcorp—a Canadian-based company.
Development and Peace also sought to follow up on the recommendations of Canada’s National
Roundtables on Corporate Social Responsibility, a multi-stakeholder process in which
the mining industry and civil society worked together to find consensus recommendations to
improve the CSR performance of Canadian companies in their overseas operations. By examining
the issue of mining in Honduras, the mission sought to show how a weak regulatory
framework allows foreign companies to take advantage, and behave in ways unacceptable in
their home countries. This, in turn, would illustrate why Canada needs to make mining, oil
and gas companies accountable for their overseas operations.
CAFOD sought to follow up on its Unearth Justice campaign, whereby campaigners in the UK
are calling on the jewelry industry to purchase only from suppliers who can guarantee responsible
production practices. With the launch by former Prime Minister Tony Blair in 2002
of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) the British government has also
been at the forefront of efforts to ensure that mining,oil and gas corporations act transparently
regarding payments and taxes paid to host governments, and this is one of the issues
at stake in Honduras.
The delegation met with a cross section of Honduran government, industry and civil society
representatives. It heard about forced relocation of families, legal improprieties by Entre
Mares, poor governance, and claims of disease caused by environmental pollution. In particular,
the delegation learned the following:
- The current 1998 mining law puts first the interests of foreign mining companies, before
those of the Honduran state. The weakness of the law was illustrated by the following
situations encountered by the delegation:
- Local mayors complained that they found out only by accident that the government had
granted mining concessions in their municipalities;
- The state prosecutor for the environment told the delegation that weak environmental
and mining legislation undermines his ability to do his job;
- Bishop Juan Jose Pineda spoke of the rampant corruption aided and abetted by unscrupulous
foreign companies;
- Entre Mares, a Goldcorp subsidiary, refused to pay a fine for environmental pollution
around the San Martin mine since it did not agree with findings of the Ministry’s environmental
tests;
- A broad cross section of civil society organizations, supported by certain key politicians,
have worked tirelessly to reform the law and bring it in line with the country’s interests,
but are repeatedly confronted by the powerful mining industry lobby which seeks to
maintain the status quo
- Mining operations have seriously depleted the water supply of the communities in the
vicinity of the San Martin mine; and
- Eight years after relocating to accommodate the San Martin mine, some families still lack
title deeds to their lands and fear future eviction.
- The Siria Valley communities living in the vicinity of the mine believe that pollution has
affected their health. The government has begun rigorous biological testing, and samples
were sent to an independent laboratory in Colombia for analysis. The results have
still not been made public.
On the eve of the delegation’s departure from Honduras, members received some good
news. Roberto Micheletti, President of the Congress, promised that the House would debate
a bill to reform the 1998 Mining Law—the product of lengthy and extensive consultations by
civil society—by the end of the parliamentary session. The MPs were convinced of the need
to strengthen regulation of mining by the Honduran government, yet at the same time, were
conscious of the fact that it will take time to implement real change. They therefore found
that as long as Canadian mining companies operate in countries of weak regulation, Canada
has a responsibility and a role to play. Consequently, the case for accountability mechanisms
for Canadian mining companies in their overseas operations is clear and unequivocal. |